[Nerd]

This is very ironic because I have just started playing Silent Hill.

I have only played Silent Hill 1, and that game is solid, except for the School. The Demon Baby's will catch you from across the hallway, and after two hits you have to use an energy drink. That gets old fast. And the boss? It took me 20 retry's to beat him, and I finally beat him they way I'm not supposed to. Other than that, the game is good I guess.

I'd also like to say that when I'm playing through any RE for the first time, I am scared shitless. After I beat it for the first time, it does become predictable. But in SH1, I wasn't scared...ever. At all. The enemy's and environments were creepy, but I have seen worse things in Castlevania.

So overall, I appreciate SH for it's complicated and immersive storyline, but it fails when it comes to scaryness and game play. Resident Evil has terrific game play and it's always scary the first time around, making it the better game.