[KevinTheOmnivore]

"My thoretical solution is to have a relationship which (both people agree that) shouldn't require compatibility on any other level than the barest essentials."

What the hell are the barest essentials? Sex and film taste?

I hit a similar cross road with a girl I was with for a few years. We're still trying out the friendship thing, but I know we can't be in a realtionship, nor could we ever get married, so what's the point?
Should we be a couple just for the sake of being a couple?

You might wanna ask yourself that.