Only ones I can think of would be about an hour and a half southeast of you, but they're ginormous and worth the trip.
http://www.tradersworldmarket.com/ is the classic one, and it's right across the freeway (75) from this one:
http://www.turtlecreeks.com/
Which is inexplicably pirate-themed and far superior.
Both are just south of the giant foam Jesus near Monroe, OH.