|
|

Jan 25th, 2006, 11:20 PM
Really Ziggy? Would you back up the argument that a Jew couldn't fairly judge a Muslim defendant in a court of Law because he's Jewish? I believe ones abilities to be a scholar, and making your lifes work translating a text should speak for itself. If it's a poor translation, then so be it. To say his motives are based in his own religious beliefs, and bias, is a stretch. There are plenty of linguists, theologists, and archeologists who provide credible studies that also happen to be Jewish.
To clear up your confusion, the concern with the liver eating woman's story goes like this: there is plenty of animosity in the Muslim world towards Jews...to label a villain as a Jew, when in fact she wasn't contributes to that climate. It's a libel. Oh and don't quit because you never started. You were the one arguing that Islam was a problem religion, while I was saying the problem was in the practice and interpretation. No hate speak here.
|
|
|
|