Acid Blinding Sentence in Iran

[Tadao]

If he is blinded then he won't really be able to throw acid on other women again. So blinding him will actually prevent him from doing this act again. I also have to believe that it would prevent a lot of acid in the face assaults.

On a side note, if in 2 weeks this becomes 5 pages of Z and P acting like fags, then I will probably lock it.

[Dr. Boogie]

Originally Posted by Tadao

If he is blinded then he won't really be able to throw acid on other women again.

"Marco."

"Marco."

"Marco."

"... polo."

*splash*

"Yeaaargh!"

[Zhukov]

I am against it, in general and in this particular case, for a few reasons.

It's not stopping future acid attacks occurring; it's reinforcing a culture of cruel violence and revenge amongst the society at the highest level. It's not telling potential acid attackers that they should treat everyone humanely and be accepting of others views; it's telling them that brutal revenge is law. This guy obviously thought the woman deserved her face disfigured for slighting him - and a bucket of acid in her face was his version of justice.

Being blind is not as efficient at stopping this particular gent from doing the same attack again as a life term in prison would be.

I think it about revenge and fulfilling sadistic wishes; the victim has said close enough to it. It's up to her whether he gets the punishment or not (and Human Rights groups, to an extent) so it's not like it's the government dishing out what it thinks is fair, either.

I don't think justice is about fairness, and I don't think it should be... but if it were about fairness, then yes, the guy would have a bucket of acid splashed in his face.

Locking up murderers, rapists, violent attackers etc, it's the best thing to do I think. When you start (or keep) killing them and being violent back to them in kind, it just keeps violence circulating in society at a higher rate than otherwise.


If Tadao is not a mod then why does he say he will lock the thread? If you are going to lock this thread because you can't handle a little arguing and perhaps some big words and more than two sentence paragraphs, then you might as well lock the News/politics board (or just not read it). What the hell else are we supposed to do in here?

[Tadao]

Originally Posted by Zhukov

If Tadao is not a mod then why does he say he will lock the thread? If you are going to lock this thread because you can't handle a little arguing and perhaps some big words and more than two sentence paragraphs, then you might as well lock the News/politics board (or just not read it). What the hell else are we supposed to do in here?

It's funny because you talk as if I give two shits about what you want.