I really enjoyed Amalur, though the game tends to wear itself out after a while...it´s just all that standart-MMO-elements that do that. Too many too unimportant quests you don´t need to do because your equipment ist WAY better than anything you could ever find in the world thanks to blacksmithing.
Still, great game, with a little fine-tuning, the next game could be truly great.
At the very least, Amalur destroys every other RPG in terms of combat. Their animations and sound-design just conveys so much impact and force...so much fun